Team Captains
| 1907-Harold Schumm |
| 1908-Richard Downey |
| 1909-Fred Rice |
| 1910-James Colliflower |
| 1911-Frank Schlosser |
| 1912-Frank Gibson, Frank Schlosser |
| 1913-Roy Waldron |
| 1914-Roy Waldron |
| 1915-Harry Kelly |
| 1916-Matt Donnelly |
| 1917-Bob O'Lone |
| 1918-Bob O'Lone |
| 1919-Fred Fees |
| 1920-Bill Dudack |
| 1921-Jack Flavin |
| 1922-Joe O'Connell |
| 1923-Andy Zazzali |
| 1924-George Carney |
| 1925-Al Brogan |
| 1926-Pete Gitlitz |
| 1927-Walter Hickey |
| 1928-Bob Nork |
| 1929-Fred Mesmer |
| 1930-Fred Mesmer |
| 1931-Walter Morris |
| 1932-Dick King |
| 1933-Johnny Crowley |
| 1934-Tom Carolan |
| 1935-Ed Hargaden |
| 1936-Don Gibeau, Ben Zola |
| 1937-Mike Petrosky |
| 1938-Mike Petrosky |
| 1939-Joe Murphy |
| 1940-John Schmitt |
| 1941-Irv Rizzi |
| 1942-Buddy O'Grady |
| 1943-Billy Hassett, Danny Kraus |
| 1946-Ken Engles |
| 1947-Danny Kraus |
| 1948-Andy Kostecka |
| 1949-Ray Corley |
| 1950-Dick Falvey |
| 1951-Danny Supkis |
| 1952-Mike Vitale |
| 1953-Bill Bolger, Hugh Beins |
| 1954-Joe Carroll, Lou Gigante |
| 1955-Game Captains |
| 1956-Jack Walsh |
| 1957-Game Captains |
| 1958-John Clark, Ken Pichette |
| 1959-Jim Oravec |
| 1960-Ed Hargaden, Jr. |
| 1961-Tom Coleman |
| 1962-Paul Tagliabue |
| 1963-Ed Lopata |
| 1964-Jim Christy |
| 1965-John Prendergast |
| 1966-Jim Brown |
| 1967-Jim Lyddy |
| 1968-Dennis Cesar, Bruce Stinebrickner |
| 1969-Jim Supple |
| 1970-Charlie Adrion, Jim Higgins |
| 1971-Bob Hannan, Don Weber |
| 1972-Mike Laughna |
| 1973-Game Captains |
| 1974-Game Captains |
| 1975-Jon Smith |
| 1976-Jon Smith, Merlin Wilson |
| 1977-Larry Long, Mike McDermott |
| 1978-Derrick Jackson |
| 1979-Steve Martin, Tom Scates |
| 1980-John Duren, Craig Shelton |
| 1981-Eric Floyd, Eric Smith, Ed Spriggs |
| 1982-Eric Floyd, Eric Smith, Ed Spriggs |
| 1983-Gene Smith |
| 1984-Gene Smith |
| 1985-Patrick Ewing |
| 1986-Ralph Dalton, Michael Jackson |
| 1987-Reggie Williams |
| 1988-Ronnie Highsmith, Perry McDonald |
| 1989-Charles Smith |
| 1990-Dwayne Bryant, Sam Jefferson, Mark Tillmon |
| 1991-Dikembe Mutombo |
| 1992-Alonzo Mourning, Ronny Thompson |
| 1993-Joey Brown |
| 1994-Joey Brown |
| 1995-Don Reid |
| 1996-Othella Harrington, Jerome Williams |
| 1997-Cheikh Dia |
| 1998-Boubacar Aw |
| 1999-Joseph Touomou |
| 2000-Rhese Gibson, Jameel Watkins |
| 2001-Ruben Boumtje-Boumtje, Kevin Braswell |
| 2002-Courtland Freeman, Kevin Braswell, Ryan Growney (mgr.) |
| 2003-Courtland Freeman, Victor Samnick, Mike Sweetney |
| 2004-Courtland Freeman, Gerald Riley |
| 2005-Game Captains |
| 2006-Ashanti Cook, Jeff Green |
| 2007-Tyler Crawford, Jeff Green |
| 2008-Tyler Crawford, Roy Hibbert, Parick Ewing Jr., Jonathan Wallace |
| 2009-Jessie Sapp |
| 2010-Chris Wright, Austin Freeman |
| 2011-Chris Wright, Austin Freeman, Ryan Dougherty |
| 2012-Jason Clark, Hollis Thompson |
| 2013-Nate Lubick, Markel Starks |
| 2014-Nate Lubick, Markel Starks |
| 2015-D'Vauntes Smith-Rivera, Jabril Trawick |
| 2016-D'Vauntes Smith-Rivera, Bradley Hayes |
| 2017-Bradley Hayes |
| 2018-No captain |
| 2019-No captain |
| 2020-No captain |
| 2021-No captain |
| 2022-Donald Carey |
| 2023-No captain |