Little is known about Al Brogan's basketball career at Georgetown but he earned the respect and support of his contemporaries. "Al has been one of the bright lights of the campus for four years," wrote the 1925 valedictory in the College yearbook. "Even at the end of a strenuous basket-ball game, he is all smiles, proof enough of his pleasing and perpetual good nature. As a captain, he tops them all, but as a smiler, he knows, no peer. "

Brogan earned a dental degree from Georgetown in 1932 and practiced in New Jersey for many years thereafter.