1957-1958 Roster
| No. | Name | Cl. | Pos. | Ht | Home Town | St | High School |
| 4 | Jack Nies | Jr | G | 5-10 | Jersey City | NJ | St. Peter's Prep |
| 5 | Dick Razzetti | So | G | 6-3 | Westbury | NY | Chaminade |
| 11 | Bob Moses | Sr | G | Syracuse | NY | Christian Brothers | |
| 12 | Jack Rafferty | So | G | Sayville | NY | Seton Hall (NJ) | |
| 17 | Ken Pichette | Sr | F | 6-3 | Binghamton | NY | Central |
| 20 | Jim Oravec | Jr | G | 6-2 | Palmerton | PA | Palmerton |
| 21 | John O'Meara | So | G | 6-2 | Baltimore | MD | Loyola |
| 21 | Henry Rojas | So | F | 6-5 | Stamford | CT | Fairfield Prep |
| 21 | Jim Brown | So | G | Merion | PA | ||
| 22 | Ed Hargaden Jr | So | G | 6-0 | Baltimore | MD | Loyola |
| 23 | Joe Titus | Sr | C | 6-6 | Bradford | PA | Bradford |
| 24 | Tom McCloskey | So | F | 6-1 | Washington | DC | Gonzaga |
| 25 | John Clark | Sr | G | 6-2 | Binghamton | NY | St. Patrick |
| 30 | Randolph Schmeling | Jr | C | 6-9 | Freeport | NY | Chaminade |
| 32 | Kevin Hennessy | So | G | Chicago | IL | Mendel | |
| Ed Frampton | Sr | G | Tuckahoe | NY | Horace Greeley |